Product Filter

2024 After Christmas Sale

  1. Home
  2. 2024 After Christmas Sale
  3. $9.99 and Under
Price
Pieces
Character
Occasion
For
Price
Pieces
Character
Occasion
For

234 products found in 2024 After Christmas Sale

Sale

Quick View Squishmallow Abbitt the Tapir 5" Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
Squishmallow Abbitt the Tapir 5" Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
  • $9.99
  • $4.99

Check back soon!

Quick View Snow Much Fun Winter Day Gnome Token Charm
Snow Much Fun Winter Day Gnome Token Charm
  • $5.99

Sale

Quick View Christmas Squishmallow Farryn the Fawn with Snowflake 3.5" Clip Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
Christmas Squishmallow Farryn the Purple Fawn with Snowflake 3.5" Clip Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
  • $7.99
  • $3.99

Sale

Quick View christmas-squishmallow-revna-the-mint-swirl-ice-cream-sandwich-with-earmuffs-5-stuffed-plush-by-kelly-toy
Christmas Squishmallow Revna The Mint Swirl Ice Cream Sandwich with Earmuffs 5" Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
  • $9.99
  • $2.99

Sale

Quick View Christmas Squishmallow Keiko the Light Blue Tree with Snow Trims 5" Stuffed Plush by Jazwares
Christmas Squishmallow Keiko the Light Blue Tree with Snow Trims 5" Stuffed Plush by Jazwares
  • $9.99
  • $5.99

Sale

Quick View Hallmark The Gift-Giving Bandit of Snowy Snowgate Book
Hallmark The Gift-Giving Bandit of Snowy Snowgate Book
  • $9.99
  • $5.99

Sale

Quick View Christmas Squishmallow Nicolette Mrs. Claus with Red Cape 5" Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
Christmas Squishmallow Nicolette Mrs. Claus with Red Cape 5" Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
  • $9.99
  • $4.99

Sale

Quick View Jingle Bell Flashing Necklace
Jingle Bell Flashing Necklace
  • $8.99
  • $4.50

Sale

Quick View Hallmark Mini Minions Just a Little Shake Ornament, 1"
Hallmark 2024 Mini Minions Just a Little Shake Ornament, 1"
  • $9.99
  • $5.99

Sale

Quick View Squishmallow Bee the Light Peach Velvet Panda with Eye Patches 3.5" Clip Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
Squishmallow Bee the Light Peach Velvet Panda with Eye Patches 3.5" Clip Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
  • $7.99
  • $3.99

Sale

Quick View Spring Squishmallow Bebe the Blue Bird with Yellow Beak and Bunny Ears 3.5" Clip Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
Spring Squishmallow Bebe the Blue Bird with Yellow Beak and Bunny Ears 3.5" Clip Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
  • $7.99
  • $3.99

Sale

Quick View Spring Squishmallow Triston the Yellow Chick Holding Flower 3.5" Clip Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
Spring Squishmallow Triston the Yellow Chick Holding Flower 3.5" Clip Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
  • $7.99
  • $3.99

Sale

Quick View Palm Pals - 5" Candace the Hot Cocoa with Peppermint Stuffed Plush
Palm Pals - 5" Candace the Hot Cocoa with Peppermint Stuffed Plush
  • $7.99
  • $4.99

Sale

Quick View Hallmark Mini Steller's Jay Ornament, 0.78"
Hallmark Mini Steller's Jay Ornament, 0.78"
  • $9.99
  • $5.99

Sale

Quick View Valentine Squishmallow Chienda the Brown Wooly Mammoth with Hearts 5" Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
Valentine Squishmallow Chienda the Brown Wooly Mammoth with Hearts 5" Stuffed Plush by Kelly Toy
  • $9.99
  • $3.99

Sale

Quick View Hallmark itty bittys® Star Wars: The Mandalorian™ Grogu™ in Holiday Sweater Plush
Hallmark itty bittys® Star Wars: The Mandalorian™ Grogu™ in Holiday Sweater Plush
  • $9.99
  • $5.99

Sale

Quick View Better Together Santa Milk Mug and Christmas Tree Cookie Magnetic Hallmark Ornaments, Set of 2
Better Together Santa Milk Mug and Christmas Tree Cookie Magnetic Hallmark Ornaments, Set of 2
  • $9.99
  • $6.99

Sale

Quick View Mr. Bird Rudolph the Red Nose Reindeer Christmas Cookie Bird Seed Ornament
Mr. Bird Rudolph the Red Nose Reindeer Christmas Cookie Bird Seed Ornament
  • $9.99
  • $5.99